And if you are a little sentimental, carburetors were the first fuel system designed. Difference between carburetor and fuel injection compare. A carburetor is dependent upon the velocity of air entering the venture to create a good airfuel mix to feed the engine, and serves to maintain the fuel circuits which pump the petrol and although the majority of current highperformance bikes have switched to fuel injection, there are still plenty of motorcycles fitted with carburetor. The good motorcycle has best carburetor which gives good acceleration, strong engine to the bike. A carburetor is very complex and needs to be adjusted properly in order to work efficiently. While a few carburetorequipped bikes are still on the.
There is a pressure pump which pressurizes the fuel which allows it to be atomized and hence inside the combustion chamber, the spray is in the form of a mist which allows for complete and cleaner combustion. It wasnt until 1980 that fuel injection made its way on a street going bike. Since fuel injection systems shoot fuel directly into the cylinders, they are easier to flood too much fuel when starting. As a result, the fuel must be metered a bit on the rich side to avoid detonation.
Plenty of go for any situation, but the primary focus was always optimum fuel economy, for me. Unfortunately, a lot can be lost in terms of this fuel system. The tuning for how much fuel is injected in a few various scenarios is all mechanical setscrews, spr. Throttle body injection is the most simple type of efi and the closest to carburetion in operation.
He actually does give a good basic breakdown of fuel injection and carburetors, as follows. Dyno testing a holley double pumper vs custom stack injection duration. Installing a procharger f1a94 in search of 8second timeslips. Turbocharged,intercooled, fuel injected, slant six. But now that you know a little more about the difference between the two systems, flying both types, and troubleshooting their problems, should be a little more simple. We have discussed the basic functional difference between fuel injection and carburetor. What is the difference between fuel injection and carburetor.
I cant seem to get it to idle properly and that it chugs consistently now at about 70 mph, like its in a vapor lock. What is the functional difference between fuel injection. In an internal combustion engine, the fuel air ratio of the fuel air mixture has significant influence on the performance of the engine, since it directly controls the power output of the engine. Some say that a carburetor is a simple and effective fuel induction method while others vouch for. Injection carburetor is a hydromechanical device employing a closed feed system from the fuel pump to the discharge nozzle. The carburetor vs fuel injection test illustrates that carb owners can stand tall, but no matter which one you choose, the holley hiram is one serious induction system. Fuel injection does everything rightimproves driveability, makes more torque, solves coldstart problems, lowers emissions, and improves gas mileage. In this video m going to explain about the difference between fuel injection and carburetorthere there are lots of confusion while going to purchase new vehicle and sometime we dont have proper. The authors reported that fuel injection had been found to have better starting, good idle, improved acceleration, and a more positive shutoff. The first fuelinjection system on a streetbike debuted in 1980, but for the most part, carbs were how motorcycles mixed air and fuel right up to the turn of the century. This is an important discussion as the fuel delivery is an important component of four stroke cycle, the engine and by extension the entire vehicle. The wikipedia injector animation may assist you in the further development of this discussion. Day by day the fuel injection system is getting more and more popular due to the enhanced performance and lower emission of fuel while there is still a huge place left where carburetors are ruling due to their easy and low cost maintenance. I believe that the reason carburetors have been our mainstay in autos and bikes is that there is lower acquisition costs for the consumer with carbureted engines.
Pressure injection carburetors of aircraft reciprocating engine are distinctly different from floattype carburetors. Was able to ride both bikes back to back during cold weather. The carburetor type motorcyle nearly has the same milleage as the fuel injection one, good. The direct fuel injection is designed to be used specifically in four or two stoke engine. A c arburetor or fuel injection, these are the two primary types of fuel delivery system typically used in cars, motorcycles, planes etc. Efi is just a more precise fuelair ratio and delivery system at all rpm ranges. Lately, the questions seems to be more, are carburetors even worthy of being considered. Nov 06, 2016 carburetor vs fuel injection which is best. A carburetor relies on a float and needs to regulate the amount of fuel passing through to the engine. By contrast, a fuel injection setup is extremely simple. Mar 12, 2017 explains the basics of airplane carburetors and fuel injection for pilots. Now that everyone knows im going with a turbo, the consensus seems to be.
Apr 18, 2015 advertisement the carburetor also spelled as carburator, carburettor, carb, or carburetter is responsible for mixing fuel with air. A servo regulator measures airflow entering the engine, and meters fuel accordingly for the proper mixture. The word carburetor comes from the french carbure meaning carbide. A pro for the fuel injected bike was instant cold start up. Jan 12, 2018 your motorcycle is either being fed fuel through a carburetor with jets, or via a throttle body with an injector. Why fuel injection has replaced carburetors on motorcycles. Keep in mind that fuel injection systems dont have a fuel reservoir, such as the bowls of a carburetor, in which fuel is stored. Carburer means to combine with carbon compare also carburizing. Subscribe to get the latest videos, articles, and quizzes that make you a smarter, safer pilot. In a carburetor system, the fuel is injected into the neck of the carburetor sort of a venturi where it mixes with air to produce charge. Efi or electronic fuel injection has been around since the 1980s on automobiles and it has finally been installed on the riding mowers. How carburettor works 3d animation in suzuki gs150r motorcycle duration. Fuel injection considerations one other item to consider is the fuel pump, as well as its relationship with the fuel pressure regulator.
The management works very hard to make sure the community is running the best software, best designs. The only down side and its not really a downside is efi requires a better fuel filtration system than a carb engine. At the cylinders, each fuel injector sprays fuel just outside of the cylinder head at the intake. Pressure injection carburetor units are throttle body, automatic mixture control, regulator unit and fuel. Carburettors allow the fuel to be sucked into the engine with air, through the inlet manifold, at a constant rate. For the most part, motorcycles and carburetors have come to a parting of the ways. Carburetor or efiwhich one is better with a supercharger. Many carburetor rebuilders have reported seeing white deposits inside the carburetors, and detailed laboratory analysis confirmed that these. When needed, the injector squirts atomized fuel into the air stream passing through the spacer plate. Carburetor vs fuel injection on holleys new hiram manifold. On the other hand, fi provides much better throttle response, if you have a fuel controller, you dont have to take your carb apart every time you want to change your fuel settings, you just push buttons.
So while the good old grease monkeys still swear by the reliability, tuneability and serviceability. There are two different versions of fuel injection port fuel injection and direct injection. Indy 500 cars started running fuel injection in 1949. How electronic fuel injection efi works how to motorcycle. Carburetor vs fuel injection ericthecarguy stay dirty.
Being the oldschool type, i only have fuel injection on the everyday drivers, so others can offer their input on that aspect of your build. On petrol engines, fuel injection replaced carburetors from the 1980s onward. Data representing the amount of power output desired by the driver sometimes known as engine load is also used by the. To measure the correct quantity of gasoline, vaporize the fuel, mix it with the air in the proper proportion and deliver the mixture to the cylinders.
The last carburetor equipped car came off the assembly line in 1990. Direct injection is the same as injectors but deliver the fuel directly into the combustion chamber, or piston space. If you spend time autocrossing, road racing, or in highg cornering situations. Injectors are the same, but time the fuel and control the amount very precisely. Which offers the best performance, carburetor or fuel injection, is highly debated question among car enthusiasts. We have a car in the shop right now that has the mega suirt on it and the owner really likes it. If the efi craps out turn on your low pressure fuel pump and away you go. While modern fuel injection engines feature materials compatible with ethanol, carburetors are made from alloys of zinc and aluminum, both of which are susceptible to corrosive properties of ethanol. To understand the difference between fuel injection and carburetor model of tvs apache rtr 200 4v we need to understand carburetor and fuel injection system as in one model the fuel supply system is carburetor while in other it is fuel injection. Crosscountry driving was 95% of the miles we put on it. Fuel injection systems are becoming more popular for those wanting the best performance from their engines. In road test, an engine supplied by a carburetor does have more power and precision.
Aside from the relatively small amount of fuel in the fuel lines and the fuel rails, no fuel is stored other than in the fuel tank. Aug 20, 2010 probably one of the most controversial discussions among motorcycle enthusiasts is the difference between carbureted and fuel injected bikes, as each of them has its own avid supporters. Carbs or fuel injection american snowmobiler magazine. For working of and more info on fuel injection read here. The fall of the carburetor how fuel injection systems work. Carburetor engines mix fuel and air in the carburetor, in fuel injector fuel mixes with the air passing through the inlet manifold or port and the fuelair mixture enters the combustion chamber. The carburetor, a device which atomises the fuel and mixes it with air.
The compression ignition engine performance will be highly dependent on the effectiveness of the fuel injection system used. Its easy to use, o maintain, and cheaper in buying and repairing in later time. Fuel injected systems work a little differently that carbureted engines, because there is no air mixed with the fuel in the metering system. Carburetor or fuel injection for b bodies only classic. I took the heritage in on a trade for a race car i was selling. This mixture is then used in cars combustion engine. With so many components working in unison, the carburetor. It got hard to ignore fuel injection around that time, anywho. This is why the fuel injection system is most vital competent in the compression ignition engines. What is the difference between a carburetor and a fuel. If i can smell unburned fuel, its got a carburetor. In fuel chemistry, the term has the more specific meaning of increasing the carbon and therefore energy content of a fluid by mixing it with a volatile hydrocarbon. Fuel injection is the introduction of fuel in an internal combustion engine, most commonly. While the direct fuel injection is the most recently developed fuel injection system, the port fuel system is still very much in use.
The fuel injection service engines are more fuel efficient, carburetors last longer. Carburetor vs fuel injected engines which one is the best. Speaking from an outsider of the world of high end engine build prospective so i will feel no ill will at being corrected. It hasnt taken long and theres already some controversy about my fairmont build. Fuel is injected above the throttle blades by one or more fuel injector nozzles. Rocket fuel injectors things kerbal space program doesnt teach duration. Carburetors may be a thing of the past, but many people still prefer the more traditional method. Fuel injected motorcycles are fast taking over carbureted ones, which until the beginning of the new millennium ruled the roost. However, carburetors do last longer than fuel injection systems and are favored in motor sports. Since fuel injection systems shoot fuel directly into the cylinders, they are. In the fuel injected engine, the fuel and air do not mix until they reach the cylinder. Small particles and impurities in the fuel can be a little more problematic with efi.
In a way, the eci system works like an efi system that reads. Both fuel and air are carried throughout the entire intake tract. Both present in internal combustion engines, carburetors and fuel injection systems accomplish similar tasks. Electronic fuel injection uses signals from several sensors located on the engine. Apr 27, 2016 fuel injected bikes are usually more costly and as well as more efficient than the carburetor ones. What is the difference between a carburetor and fuel injection for internal combustion engines. As things stand today, almost every premium motorcycle comes equipped with an fi system. Thats because of the main advantage that injection has over carburetion.
Unless you want to keep your ride 100% factory correct for seriously judged shows and such, wed suggest jumping aboard the injection express. Fuel injection doesnt give appreciably more power, and it doesnt provide much better gas mileage. Fuel injector vs carburetor gasoline, motor oils, concept. Fuel injection does allow for more accurate control of the airfuel ratio, and in doing so, allows a bike to run cleaner and keep a catalytic converter on board. Electronic fuel injection august 1, 2017 7219 views no comments these days carburetors have mostly been banished from newly produced vehicles due to electronic fuel injection, but there a ton of people who still love and enjoy them. The carburetor type motorcycle is always the number1 choice. I guess what im struggling with is the advantage of having a lighter, more simple carbureted engine that would be cheaper to repair vs having something that is clearly a technological advancement that is arguably less likely to need adjustments etc.
Carbureted and fuel injected engines have their pros and cons. May 06, 2008 fuel injection meters the fuel much more precisely than the carburetor. Find out how fuel injection systems work and about the various configurations used in the cars today. It replaced the carburetor with one or two fuelinjector nozzles in the throat of the engines.
Jun 30, 2016 the primary difference between carburetors and fuel injection is that fuel injection atomizes the fuel through a small nozzle under high pressure, while a carburetor relies on suction created by intake air accelerated through a venturi tube to draw the fuel into the airstream 3. With a carburetor engine, one cylinder will receive more fuel than another cylinder. The story from carburetor to electronic fuel injection. I am at a point of either replacing the carburetor again, or going to fuel injection system. Sumped tanks normally accept aluminum an fittings and braided stainless steel fuel lines to carry the fuel to the carburetor. Car enthusiasts always have conflicting opinions over the pros and cons of using carburetor vs fuel injection. The mixture then goes to each cylinder through the air intakes. Furthermore, this rich mixture is used throughout the race and robs precious fuel economy. Your motorcycle is either being fed fuel through a carburetor with jets, or via a. I can typically tell if a cars engine is carbureted or injected just by smelling the exhaust as the car passes me. The air intake is measured by the air sensor location inside. In carbureted systems the fuel gets drawn from the tank, while in a fuel injected system it depends on a fuel pump installed inside the tank for a finegrained control over fuel flow. Again, because fuel injection and modern electronic controls are more accurate, fuel delivery can be tuned to match driver demand.
Edelbrock electronic fuel injection installation and performance. I think fuel injection took over because of emission control and you dont need the pump the carb thing to start a car. Get fuel injection benefits while retaining your classics. Carburettors and electronic fuel injection systems are devices used to mix fuel and air with a proper ratio and control the fuel air mixture given to the engine. The carburetor is currently much less expensive than the electronic fuel injection systems.
Disconnect the fuel supply and stopper it to keep it from leaking. For working of and more info on carburetor read here. Thats because of the main advantage that injection. However, when comparing carburetors vs fuel injection, it is important to note the two function differently. The system consists of a carb spacer plate with a fuel block and injector, an ecu, and a wide band o2 sensor. Aug 15, 2011 read as the editor discusses carburetor versus fuel injection. Carburetor vs fuel injection is debated as fuel delivery systems.
Carburetors are also much simpler to install than fuel injection systems, because there are no electrical components or return lines to the fuel tank. With an older performance car, should you keep the old carbs or make the switch to fuel injection. Your motorcycle is either being fed fuel through a carburetor with jets, or via a throttle body with an injector. The carburetor meters fuel only by mechanical linkage and engine manifold vacuum. On the flip side, a multipoint fuel injection system delivers a separate fuel charge to each cylinder, and is thus immune to the effects of centrifugal force. Port fuel injection is the most widely utilized form of injection today. Perhaps not all the bikers know about the functionality of a carburetor on their motorcycle or has a very little interest in it. They are of two variants the direct injection and the port fuel injection. Carburetors vs fuel injection muscle mustangs and fast. Carefully lift the carburetor off and set it in a container to drain. One day its totally fine then the next it runs like, well i will say crap. Look forward to the conclusion of this post in the next few weeks, in the meantime check out a few of these links that will help you understand the fuel injection systems, air induction systems and ignition systems available for your classic car, muscle car, street or rat rod.
In most modern cars, carburetors are replaced by fuel injection systems. In carbureted engines, the fuel air mixture meets in the carburetor. Sac power strategy dyna dyno tuning ecu software upgrades. Disconnect the throttle and kickdown if equipped linkage from the carburetor and set these out of your way. Jan 27, 2012 the carburetor is currently much less expensive than the electronic fuel injection systems. Carburetor vs fuel injection summit racing 101 youtube. The fuel injection nozzle is provided directly in the combustion chamber. Every bike in my garage thats a total of eight has a carburetor. What you could do is use the carb as the throttle body of the efi system. Difference between fuel injection and carburetor fi vs. Based on these signals, a computer decides the best fuel air mixture for the engine.
Although most small engines use the carburetor system for its simplicity and cheap prices, and less maintenance costs, fuel injection is the perfect choice for the modern vehicles for better performance, lower emissions, and fuel economy. You must select a pump that will flow the required amount at the planned pressure. The fuel and the air both meet the engine and then enter the carburetor. A pressure carburetor injects the fuel into the airflow instead of the air drawing the fuel from a nozzle. Carburetor vs fuel injection motorcycle fuel systems. Unlike carburetors, a fuel injection system is comprised of a complex set of electronics and sensors. Since then, fuel injectors have been the primary means of getting gasoline into the engine cylinder so it can combust and you can drive. Carburetors are heavier than fuel injection systems.
How can i know and troubleshoot common fuel injector issues. Should i buy a fuel injected or carburetor riding lawn mower. To view the carburetor version is the cub cadet xt1 lt46. The process of preparing this mixture is called carburetion. At jds auto repair, we can always explain the mechanics in detail. However, on roads, you will find many cars that still use carburetors.
975 1094 825 1007 1513 1482 628 398 845 331 583 1163 639 835 316 597 191 1231 858 1319 69 1121 1017 797 135 1263 1273 1021 99 1264 2 813 776 1261 910 1399 648 560 116 1329 1349